【Economist】Banyan: Who do they think they are?

2021-02-21 新英文雜誌

中文導讀

第32屆夏季奧林匹克運動會將於2020年7月24日至8月9日在日本東京舉行。這是東京繼1964年之後再次主辦夏季奧運會,當時的日本是世界上的科技巨頭。而如今的日本面臨著眾多難題,如人口老齡化、經濟低迷等。但從古至今,日本人一直在不斷構建和調整自己的身份認同,即使當今困難重重,但跟以往遇到的危機相比或許都不是大問題。

A more prominent role on the world stage is prompting Japan to ponder its identity

The eyes of the world will be upon Japan next summer when Tokyo hosts the Olympics. Of that, the country is acutely aware. Barely a week goes by without mention of the attention that the games will bring. This has been used to argue for everything from curbs on single-use plastic to changes in the way Japanese names are written in English. The country is not accustomed to being centre stage. Its response betrays its insecurities, not least because Japan is no longer the leader in technology it was when it last hosted the summer Olympics, in 1964.

All countries ponder their identity but Japan does so more than many. An entire genre of literature, Nihonjinron—「theories about the Japanese」—is dedicated to the question of what defines the country and what it means to be Japanese. Both locals and foreigners have gamely tried to come up with answers.

Historically, Japan’s identity is particularly fraught thanks to a poisonous strain of thought about the uniqueness and superiority of the Japanese race. Traditionalists once saw the Japanese as a chosen people (some still do). By their account, the emperor is descended directly from the sun goddess (even if the post-war order stripped him of his divinity). This idea fed Japan’s colonisation of parts of Asia and inspired its troops in the second world war.

Its defeat in that war, and America’s subsequent occupation and castration of Japan militarily, destroyed the power of that identity—and the country’s self-esteem. In its place Japan sought, and found, a new narrative: since 1945, goes the tale, the collective effort of its people has transformed the country into a developed nation with a powerful economy that is—crucially—pacifist.

That idea was shaken in the early 1990s when its economic bubble burst and it lost two decades to sluggish growth. Japan sought comfort in a new version of the post-war narrative: its ability to overcome adversity and rebound, epitomised by its resilience after the Fukushima disaster of 2011. Today Japan sees its ability to bounce back after crises as central to what it means to be Japanese, argues David Leheny of Waseda University in Tokyo.

But the contradictions within Japan’s sense of identity compound its insecurity. It wants both to stand out and to fit in. It strives to be a nation that is advanced and respected globally, but not feared. It is influenced by Asia and America in equal measure. Japan commands respect from other rich nations, but is an uneasy member of their clubs. Unlike Germany, it has never fully reckoned with its wartime past.

That Japan is rapidly becoming less socially homogenous threatens its understanding of itself, too. The model of the salaryman who enjoys a job for life has broken down. Families, the building block of society, come in many more forms. Foreigners now live and work in Japan in record numbers. Such changes are exposing how overblown the claims of the homogeneity and togetherness of the Japanese were in the first place, reckons Akiko Hashimoto, a sociologist at the University of Pittsburgh.

This strikes fear into some. The response of diehard revisionists, including a few close to the prime minister, Shinzo Abe, is to look backwards. They talk of making Japan great again, inspired by a glorious, if often fictionalised, past. Some are pushing to change the constitution, written by the United States in 1947, in particular to make Japan a normal military power. Others focus on putting a divine emperor and the Shinto religion back at the heart of Japan’s identity, even if that was largely devised in the Meiji restoration of 1868, reinventing tradition for the purposes of the creation of a modern constitutional state.

Since that moment Japan has in fact been remarkably adept at changing. It took on Western forms of economic, military and governmental organisation in order to fight off Western imperialism. After Japan’s defeat in the second world war, its transformation from a country in ruins to the world’s third-largest economy, from warmaker to peaceable nation—it has not fired a single bullet in anger since the end of the second world war—is extraordinary.

The dichotomies of its identity today make it intriguing, as evidenced by the ever-rising numbers of foreign visitors. Other countries dream of having Japan’s problems. Its worries about demographic change, an economy that no longer fizzes and a relatively less visible role in the world are nothing compared with its earlier challenges. Japan remains impressive in its own right.

——

July 27th 2019 | Asia | 777 words

China's slowing growth: Get used to it

中國經濟增長放緩:習慣就好

Johnson: The poetry of emoji

詹森:表情符號的藝術

Investment migrants: Golden parachutes

投資移民:黃金降落傘

如果覺得獨自學習效率不高

歡迎掃下方二維碼了解閱讀訓練營哦

相關焦點

  • The Economist Asks: Philippe Reines
    0:05  You're listening to the economist ask Sam and McIlroy. And this week we're asking, how do you win or lose the presidential debate? Nothing is straightforward.
  • 【Economist】Banyan: Squeeze of access
    Yet to judge by how much Chinese officials have harangued American diplomats and congressmen about who was going to attend the ceremony in Taiwan’s capital, China appears to care every bit as much and
  • The Economist Asks: What next for Germany after Merkel?
    What do you think about that? Well, I think you're absolutely right. You're absolutely right. The only point I would make is, it wasn't only an illusion for us Germans.
  • Do You Think So?
    Recently, a white girl called Keziah Daum, 18-year-old from Utah in the United States, who has no Chinese roots, was accused of 「cultural appropriation」 after posting photographs
  • 【Economist】Free exchange: Progress of a sort
    Over the past few decades, gender gaps in the rich world have had ever less to do with overt discrimination, she argued, and ever more to do with women’s decisions.
  • Agents scamming expats in China: what to look for and what to do
    have been bamboozled by agents who purport to work in the education industry."For the students, it is illegal, but we should also take action to eradicate fake agents and deceivers who take advantage of newcomers who do not know the society and market," said John.
  • Be Entrepreneurial in Everything You Do
    You can be entrepreneurial in everything you do. Everyone has the capacity to dream big, be intellectually curious and solve problems.
  • 【Economist】Colour vision
    This is prompting a complex and heated debate about how, and whether, to think about race.If Mr Macron has decided to do more about racial discrimination, though, this does not mean that he shares the way that some activists in France seek to steer the debate.
  • 5 Things Highly Respected People Do Every Day
    But how do you go about earning this respect?We do know that reading helps develop a variety of skills and traits that ultimately help build respect.
  • The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas
    I do not know the rules and laws of their society, but I suspect that they were singularly few.I think that there would be no cars or helicopters in and above the streets; this follows from the fact that the people of Omelas are happy people.
  • 【樂賞】勵志英文短片:How do you spend your time?
    來源:騰訊視頻See whatever you are doing, however you spend your time that tells who you are, so think about what it is you like to create in your life experience.
  • YPDP Workshop 4: How to Think Strategically in Business
    It is time to 「think differently about how to live in the world」 and pre-emptively develop the skills that 「machines can't do.」
  • Writing:What do we Strive For?
    Writing: What do we Strive For?Part I.
  • 【Economist】China's economy: The real deal
    Doubts about China’s data are not new: it is probably fair to say that few serious economists trust its exact growth figures. Instead, there are two broad camps.
  • 【Economist】Fighting groping in Japan: Pervert alert
    Some hold back out of fear and embarrassment; others because they do not want to be late for school or work. 「We are socialised to think that groping is not a big deal,」 says Ms Woo.