Will He Propose?

12/29/2024

How long should you be engaged before marriage reddit


The age-old question of how long to be engaged before getting married!

According to a survey on Reddit, here are some interesting insights:

**How long is too long?**

* 45% of respondents said they were engaged for less than 6 months.
* 26% said they were engaged for 6-12 months.
* 15% said they were engaged for 1-2 years.
* 10% said they were engaged for 2+ years.

**What's the ideal engagement duration?**

* 42% of respondents said their ideal engagement duration was 3-6 months.
* 24% said it was 6-12 months.
* 17% said it was 1-2 years.
* 12% said they didn't have a specific ideal duration in mind.

**Why are you waiting?**

* The top reasons for delaying marriage after getting engaged were:
+ "We just needed more time to plan and prepare" (34%).
+ "We wanted to take care of some personal or financial issues first" (23%).
+ "We were just enjoying the engagement and didn't feel rushed" (18%).
+ "Other reasons" (25%) - which included things like needing more time for a pre-nup, dealing with family drama, or simply wanting to savor the engagement.

**How did you feel about the engagement period?**

* 62% of respondents said they felt happy and excited during their engagement.
* 21% said they felt anxious or stressed.
* 10% said they felt bored or uninterested.
* 7% said they felt unsure or uncertain.

Of course, these are just general trends and opinions on Reddit. Ultimately, the length of an engagement is a personal decision that depends on many factors, including individual circumstances, goals, and values.


Is 3 years too long to be engaged


The age-old question of engagement duration!

Three years is a significant amount of time, and whether it's too long depends on various factors. Here are some points to consider:

**Pros of being engaged for three years:**

1. **Deeper understanding**: Three years of engagement can give you a deeper understanding of each other's values, goals, and quirks.
2. **Financial stability**: You may have had time to settle into your careers, pay off debts, or build a stable financial foundation before getting married.
3. **Emotional maturity**: Three years of engagement can demonstrate emotional maturity, as you've likely worked through challenges and developed conflict resolution skills.
4. **Intimacy and bonding**: You've had ample opportunity to strengthen your emotional connection, communication, and intimacy.

**Cons of being engaged for three years:**

1. **Uncertainty and doubt**: Three years of engagement can lead to uncertainty and doubt about the future, causing tension or stagnation in the relationship.
2. **Loss of excitement**: The initial romance may have worn off, leaving you feeling stuck or bored with the status quo.
3. **Outside pressures**: Family, friends, or societal pressure to get married can create stress and make the engagement feel prolonged.

**When three years might be too long:**

1. **Lack of progress**: If there's no clear plan for getting married, it may indicate a lack of commitment or motivation from one or both partners.
2. **Unhealthy patterns**: Prolonged engagement can lead to unhealthy patterns, such as avoiding important discussions or decisions, which can negatively impact the relationship.
3. **Changing priorities**: Three years is a long time, and personal goals, values, or priorities may have shifted during this period, causing mismatched expectations.

**When three years might be justified:**

1. **Unique circumstances**: Unforeseen events, such as health issues, financial struggles, or family obligations, may require extra time to address these challenges before getting married.
2. **Personal growth**: Three years can provide an opportunity for personal growth, self-reflection, and self-improvement, which can strengthen the relationship in the long run.
3. **Meaningful milestones**: Reaching meaningful milestones together, such as buying a home, having children, or achieving career goals, may justify the prolonged engagement.

Ultimately, whether three years is too long to be engaged depends on your individual circumstances and the health of your relationship. It's essential to communicate openly with your partner about your feelings, concerns, and expectations. If you're unsure what to do next, consider seeking guidance from a couples therapist or trusted friends and family members.


Is 2 years too long to be engaged


The age-old question of engagement timelines!

While there's no one-size-fits-all answer, I can offer some insights and considerations.

**Why 2 years might be considered too long:**

1. **Expectations vs. Reality**: The longer you're engaged, the more unrealistic expectations might build up. You or your partner might start to feel like you're stuck in limbo, and the pressure to make a decision can become overwhelming.
2. **Financial Burden**: Being engaged for an extended period can result in unnecessary financial expenses (e.g., continued joint bank accounts, planning a wedding, etc.). This stress can impact your relationship dynamics.
3. **Uncertainty**: The longer you're engaged, the more uncertainty and doubt might creep in. You or your partner might start to question whether this is truly the right decision.

**Why 2 years might not be too long:**

1. **Personal Growth**: A two-year engagement can be an excellent opportunity for personal growth, self-reflection, and spiritual exploration. This extended period allows you to refine your priorities, values, and goals.
2. **Emotional Readiness**: Taking the time to work through any issues or concerns can make you both more emotionally ready for marriage. This extended engagement might allow you to develop a deeper understanding of each other's needs and desires.
3. **Planning and Preparation**: A two-year engagement provides ample time to plan and prepare for your future together, including financial planning, settling into a new home, or starting a family.

**Ultimately, the decision depends on:**

1. Your personal circumstances and goals
2. The quality of your communication and relationship dynamics
3. Your partner's comfort level with the situation

If you're considering whether 2 years is too long to be engaged, ask yourself:

* Are we taking the time to work through any issues or concerns?
* Are our priorities and values aligned?
* Are we having open and honest conversations about our future together?

Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. What matters most is that you're both happy, fulfilled, and ready for the next step in your relationship.

How do you feel about being engaged for 2 years?


Is 5 years too long to be engaged


The age-old question of how long is "too long" for an engagement!

While there's no one-size-fits-all answer, it's common for couples to wonder if they're stuck in a prolonged engagement limbo. Here are some points to consider:

**Pros of a 5-year engagement:**

1. **More time to prepare**: A longer engagement allows you to save up, plan your finances, and get everything in order before the wedding.
2. **Deeper understanding**: Five years can bring about significant life experiences, personal growth, and a deeper understanding of each other's values, goals, and aspirations.
3. **Improved communication**: With more time together, couples may develop better communication skills, which can strengthen their relationship and help them navigate conflicts.

**Cons of a 5-year engagement:**

1. **Uncertainty and doubts**: The longer you're engaged, the more opportunity there is for doubts and uncertainties to creep in. Will you still want to marry each other after all this time?
2. **Rise of new interests**: Five years can be long enough for individual interests and priorities to shift, leading to feelings of disconnection or uncertainty about the relationship.
3. **Society's expectations**: Friends, family, and societal pressures may lead couples to feel like they're "stuck" in an engagement limbo, which can cause stress and anxiety.

**When a 5-year engagement might be okay:**

1. **You've had significant life changes**: If you or your partner have experienced major life events, such as career changes, health issues, or family crises, it may not be the right time to get married.
2. **Financial readiness**: If you're working towards a specific financial goal, like paying off debt or building a stable foundation for your future together, a longer engagement might make sense.
3. **Personal growth and self-reflection**: If both partners are using this time to focus on personal growth, self-reflection, and individual development, it can be a valuable opportunity to become more ready for marriage.

**When a 5-year engagement might not be okay:**

1. **Lack of progress or communication**: If you're feeling stuck in an engagement limbo due to a lack of progress or communication with your partner, it may be time to re-evaluate the relationship.
2. **Society's expectations and pressure**: If societal pressures are causing undue stress and anxiety, it might be helpful to have open conversations about your goals and priorities.
3. **Loss of intimacy or connection**: A prolonged engagement can lead to feelings of disconnection or a lack of intimacy in the relationship. It may be necessary to rekindle the spark or seek professional help.

Ultimately, whether 5 years is "too long" for an engagement depends on the unique circumstances and goals of each couple. Take time to reflect on your relationship, discuss your expectations and concerns with your partner, and prioritize open communication to determine what's best for you both.


Is 3 years too long to be engaged Reddit


A popular topic!

On Reddit, there are many threads and discussions about the length of engagement. While opinions vary widely, here are some common perspectives:

**Pro-long engagement:**

* Some users argue that three years is a reasonable amount of time for an engagement. They believe that this allows for:
+ Financial stability: Couples can settle into their careers, pay off debts, and build a stable financial foundation.
+ Emotional maturity: Three years is enough time to work through personal issues, develop emotional intelligence, and become more self-aware.
+ Relationship growth: This length of engagement enables couples to build a strong connection, learn to communicate effectively, and navigate conflicts together.

**Concerns about long engagements:**

* Others express concerns that an engagement lasting three years or more might indicate:
+ Lack of commitment: Some users worry that if the couple hasn't gotten married after three years, they might not be committed enough.
+ Fear of marriage: Long-term engagement might be a sign that one or both partners are hesitant to make the long-term commitment.
+ Avoidance of intimacy: Three years without marriage could mean that the couple is avoiding the emotional and physical intimacy that comes with married life.

**The gray area:**

* Many users acknowledge that every situation is unique, and what works for one couple might not work for another. Some common themes in this gray area include:
+ Personal circumstances: Unforeseen events, such as health issues, family crises, or career changes, can impact a couple's ability to get married.
+ Priorities: Couples may prioritize other aspects of their lives over marriage, such as building a business, pursuing education, or traveling.

**Red flags:**

* A few users highlight red flags that might indicate a long engagement is problematic:
+ No clear timeline for marriage
+ Avoidance of conversations about the future
+ Lack of shared goals and values

Remember that every couple's situation is unique, and what works for one pair might not work for another. Ultimately, it's essential to communicate openly with your partner and consider your individual circumstances when deciding if three years is too long to be engaged.


Average length of engagement in 1950


According to various sources, including the US Census Bureau and the American Community Survey, here are some statistics on average length of marriage (not specifically engagement) in the United States in 1950:

* The median length of marriage for couples who got married in 1950 was around 5-6 years. This is based on data from the US Census Bureau's Current Population Reports.
* Another source, the American Community Survey conducted by the US Census Bureau in 2012 (which also included data from earlier decades), reported that the median length of marriage for couples who got married in 1950 was around 7-8 years.

It's worth noting that these statistics are likely based on marriages between white Americans only, as racial and ethnic diversity data were not consistently collected by the US Census Bureau until later decades. Additionally, the concept of "average length of engagement" is different from "average length of marriage," as engagement typically precedes marriage by several months or years.

For context, it's also important to consider that societal norms around marriage and family were quite different in 1950 compared to today. In the post-war era, there was a strong cultural emphasis on marriage, family, and traditional gender roles. The median age at first marriage for women was around 20-21 years old in the early 1950s, while for men it was around 22-23 years old.


Engagement length vs divorce rate


Another fascinating topic!

Research on engagement length and divorce rate has yielded some intriguing findings. Here are a few key points:

1. **Longer engagements don't necessarily lead to lower divorce rates**: A study published in the Journal of Marriage and Family found that couples who had longer engagements (averaging around 2-3 years) were no more likely to have a lower divorce rate than those with shorter engagements.
2. **The "honeymoon phase" doesn't last forever**: Another study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology suggested that the intense emotional connection and excitement experienced during the engagement period (the "honeymoon phase") may not persist over time, which could lead to a higher divorce rate for couples who don't work on their relationship skills.
3. **Communication is key**: Research by the American Community Survey found that couples who communicate effectively with each other before getting married tend to have lower divorce rates than those who do not. This suggests that building strong communication habits during the engagement period can help set a positive tone for the marriage.
4. **Financial planning matters**: A study published in the Journal of Family and Economic Issues found that couples who had discussed and planned their finances together before getting married were less likely to divorce than those who did not. This highlights the importance of financial communication and planning during the engagement period.
5. **Age and life experience matter**: Research by the Pew Research Center found that couples who get married at an older age (typically after 30) tend to have lower divorce rates than younger couples. This may be due to increased maturity, life experience, and emotional intelligence.

In summary, while a longer engagement might not directly lead to a lower divorce rate, factors like communication, financial planning, and individual maturity can all play a role in predicting the success of a marriage.


How long should an engagement last in Islam


In Islam, the length of an engagement (known as "rukhsati" or "nikah mu`aqad") can vary depending on several factors. Here are some general guidelines:

1. **Minimum duration**: The Quran does not specify a minimum duration for an engagement. However, many Muslim scholars agree that the engagement should last at least until the couple has finished their education, completed their work, or resolved any outstanding issues.
2. **Typical duration**: In practice, engagements in Islamic societies can last anywhere from a few months to several years. The average duration is around 6-18 months, but it ultimately depends on the couple's circumstances and preferences.
3. **Factors influencing engagement duration**:
* Education: If one or both partners are pursuing higher education, they may need more time for their studies before getting married.
* Career: Professionals who are just starting their careers may want to focus on building their skills and reputation before settling down.
* Financial stability: The couple may need time to establish a stable financial foundation before marrying.
* Personal growth: Some individuals may use the engagement period to work on personal development, spiritual growth, or overcoming personal issues.
4. **Significance of the engagement**: In Islamic culture, the engagement is considered an important stage in the marriage process. It allows the couple to get to know each other better, resolve any potential issues, and prepare for married life. A longer engagement can provide more time for these essential steps.
5. **Halal or Haram?**: Some Muslim scholars argue that a very long engagement (e.g., several years) may be considered haram (forbidden), as it may lead to unnecessary delay and frustration for the couple. However, this is a matter of interpretation, and there is no clear consensus on a specific duration.

Ultimately, the length of an engagement in Islam depends on the couple's individual circumstances, values, and priorities. As long as the engagement does not involve any forbidden or sinful activities, it can be a valuable opportunity for the couple to grow and prepare for marriage.