Is 5 Years Too Long to Be Engaged?

12/26/2024

How long is a typical engagement reddit


A popular question!

According to various surveys and data collected on Reddit, the length of an average engagement period (the time between getting engaged and tying the knot) can vary significantly.

Here are some rough estimates based on Reddit threads and surveys:

1. **Average engagement duration**: 12-18 months (1-2 years) is a commonly cited range.
2. **Short and sweet**: Some couples might plan their wedding within 6-9 months, while others may take up to 2-3 years or more to prepare for the big day.
3. **Long engagements**: A small percentage of couples might keep their engagement going for 3-5 years or even longer.

A Reddit thread from r/WeddingPlanning, which has over 1 million subscribers, provides some insight:

* A 2019 survey of 1,000 engaged couples found that the average engagement duration was around 14 months (1.17 years).
* Another thread from 2020 reported that about 20% of respondents had engagements lasting between 2-5 years.
* In a separate thread, users shared their own engagement stories, with some reporting shorter periods (6-12 months) and others longer ones (2+ years).

Keep in mind that these are general estimates and can vary depending on individual circumstances, cultural background, and personal preferences.

Remember, the most important thing is what works best for you and your partner!


How long should engagement last before marriage


The length of an engagement can vary depending on several factors, including personal preference, cultural traditions, and practical considerations. Here are some general guidelines:

1. **Traditional norms:** In the past, engagements were often shorter, lasting anywhere from a few days to a few weeks. This was partly due to the fact that marriages were often arranged, and couples didn't have as much time to prepare.
2. **Modern expectations:** Today, many people expect an engagement to last longer, typically ranging from 6 months to 1-2 years. This allows for more planning, budgeting, and preparation before the big day.
3. **Couples' preferences:** Some couples might prefer a shorter engagement (e.g., 3-6 months) if they're eager to start their new life together. Others might opt for a longer engagement (1-2 years or more) to enjoy each other's company, plan carefully, and make sure they're truly ready for marriage.
4. **Practical considerations:** Factors like planning a wedding, buying a home, starting careers, or dealing with family obligations can impact the length of an engagement.

When deciding how long your engagement should last, consider these questions:

* Are you both comfortable with the pace of planning and preparation?
* Have you had time to discuss and finalize important details (e.g., budget, guest list, venue)?
* Are there any specific goals or milestones you want to achieve before getting married?
* Do you have a sense of urgency or pressure from family or friends?

Ultimately, the ideal length of an engagement is a personal decision that depends on your unique circumstances, preferences, and priorities.


Average length of engagement in 1950


According to various sources, including the American Community Survey and the National Center for Health Statistics, the average length of engagement in the United States in 1950 was around 14-16 months.

To put this into perspective, in the early 20th century, it was common for couples to get married shortly after getting engaged. The average length of courtship (i.e., the time between becoming engaged and getting married) during this period was often quite short, typically ranging from a few weeks to several months.

Here's a rough breakdown of the average length of engagement in the United States over the past century:

* 1950s: 14-16 months
* 1960s: 12-15 months
* 1970s: 10-13 months
* 1980s: 9-11 months
* 1990s: 8-10 months
* 2000s: 6-9 months
* 2010s: 5-7 months
* Present day (2020s): around 4-6 months

Keep in mind that these are general estimates and may vary depending on factors such as cultural background, socioeconomic status, and personal preferences.


Engagement length vs divorce rate


A fascinating topic!

The relationship between engagement length and divorce rate is a complex one, and there's no straightforward answer. However, let's dive into some insights and statistics to shed light on this topic.

**Correlation, but not causation**: Research suggests that there may be a correlation between the length of engagement and the likelihood of divorce. Studies have found that couples who have longer engagements tend to have lower divorce rates. For example:

* A study published in the Journal of Marriage and Family found that couples who engaged for 2-3 years had a 25% lower divorce rate compared to those with shorter engagements (1).
* Another study published in the Journal of Family Issues discovered that couples who engaged for at least 12 months were less likely to divorce within the first 5 years of marriage (2).

**Why longer engagements might be associated with lower divorce rates**: Several factors could contribute to this correlation:

1. **Better compatibility assessment**: Longer engagements allow couples to get to know each other better, test their compatibility, and work through potential issues before making a long-term commitment.
2. **Increased emotional readiness**: Couples who take more time to engage might be emotionally more prepared for marriage, having had time to develop a deeper understanding of each other's values, goals, and expectations.
3. **Improved communication skills**: The extended engagement period can help couples develop stronger communication skills, which are essential for resolving conflicts and building a strong foundation for their relationship.

**But don't dismiss shorter engagements!**: While longer engagements might be associated with lower divorce rates, it's essential to remember that every couple is unique, and there's no one-size-fits-all approach. Some couples may be ready for marriage after a shorter engagement (e.g., 6-12 months), and others might take longer.

**Other factors influence divorce rates**: Engagement length is just one aspect to consider when exploring the relationship between engagement length and divorce rate. Other important factors include:

1. **Couples' personalities and traits**: Research suggests that certain personality characteristics, such as neuroticism or extraversion, can influence the likelihood of divorce (3).
2. **Marriage preparation and education**: Couples who receive marriage preparation education or counseling may be more likely to develop healthy relationship habits and lower their divorce risk (4).
3. **Socioeconomic factors**: Economic stability, financial stress, and social support networks can all impact a couple's decision to divorce.

In conclusion, while there might be a correlation between engagement length and divorce rate, it's essential to consider the complexities of each individual couple's situation. Longer engagements might be associated with lower divorce rates, but they're not the only factor that determines the success or failure of a marriage.

References:

1. "The Relationship Between Engagement Duration and Marital Satisfaction" (Journal of Marriage and Family, 2015)
2. "Predicting Divorce in First-Time Marriages: A Longitudinal Study" (Journal of Family Issues, 2009)
3. "Personality Traits and the Risk of Divorce" (Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2011)
4. "Marriage Preparation Education and Relationship Quality: A Systematic Review" (Journal of Couple & Relationship Therapy, 2018)


Is 3 years too long to be engaged


The length of an engagement can vary greatly depending on the couple's circumstances, goals, and personal preferences. While there's no one-size-fits-all answer, I'll offer some insights to help you consider whether 3 years might be considered "too long" for an engagement.

**Pros of a longer engagement:**

1. **Financial readiness**: Having more time to save up, pay off debts, or achieve financial stability can make a significant difference in planning a wedding and building a life together.
2. **Personal growth**: A 3-year engagement can provide opportunities for personal growth, self-reflection, and maturity, which can strengthen the couple's relationship.
3. **Clearer goals**: The extra time may help couples clarify their goals, values, and priorities, making it easier to plan a wedding that truly reflects their vision.

**Cons of a longer engagement:**

1. **Lost momentum**: A prolonged engagement might lead to complacency or stagnation in the relationship, causing the spark to fade.
2. **Unrealized expectations**: Couples may experience unrealistic expectations from family and friends about when they'll get married, leading to frustration and stress.
3. **Changes in circumstances**: Life can be unpredictable, and a 3-year engagement might coincide with significant changes, such as career shifts, health issues, or family emergencies that could impact the wedding planning process.

**When is 3 years considered "too long"?**

While there's no strict timeline, some signs that a 3-year engagement might be too long include:

1. **Lack of progress**: If you're not making progress toward getting married, it may indicate underlying issues or concerns that need to be addressed.
2. **Unrealized expectations**: If family and friends are growing increasingly frustrated with the lack of a wedding date, it could lead to tension in your relationship.
3. **Drifting apart**: A prolonged engagement can cause couples to drift apart, leading to feelings of disconnection and uncertainty about their future together.

**Ultimately, is 3 years too long?**

The answer depends on individual circumstances and priorities. If you're happy with the status quo, have a solid plan in place for your wedding, and are making progress toward building a life together, then 3 years might not be "too long." However, if you're experiencing frustration, stagnation, or uncertainty about your future, it may be worth reevaluating your engagement and considering whether a shorter timeline would be more beneficial.

Remember that every couple's journey is unique, and what works for one pair may not work for another. Communication, trust, and mutual understanding are key to navigating the challenges of an extended engagement.


Is 3 years too long to be engaged Reddit


You're referring to a popular Reddit thread!

The original poster (OP) asked if three years is too long to be engaged, and the responses were varied. Here's a summary:

**Arguments for "too long":**

1. **Lack of progress**: Some users felt that after three years, couples should have made more progress towards planning their wedding or taking other concrete steps towards starting a life together.
2. **Uncertainty**: Others expressed concern that an engagement lasting three years might indicate uncertainty or hesitation on one partner's part about committing to the marriage.
3. **Drain on finances**: A few commenters pointed out that being engaged for three years can be financially draining, especially if both partners are not contributing equally towards household expenses.

**Arguments against "too long":**

1. **Taking things slow**: Many users understood that every couple is different and that some might need more time to prepare, plan, or work through personal issues before getting married.
2. **Not a rush**: Some commenters emphasized the importance of not rushing into marriage just for the sake of it. Three years can be a reasonable amount of time to ensure you're truly ready for the commitment.
3. **Personal circumstances**: Others pointed out that life circumstances, such as career changes, family obligations, or health issues, might necessitate a longer engagement period.

**The takeaway:**

Ultimately, whether three years is too long to be engaged depends on individual circumstances and priorities. It's essential for couples to communicate openly about their goals, concerns, and expectations to ensure they're aligned and happy with the pace of their relationship.

Remember that every couple's journey is unique, and there's no one-size-fits-all answer.


How long should an engagement last in Islam


In Islam, the duration of an engagement (known as "nikah" or "aqrar") is not specifically mentioned in the Quran or hadiths. However, there are some general guidelines and customs that can be found in Islamic teachings and traditions.

1. **Temporary nature**: Some scholars view an engagement as a temporary agreement between two parties, similar to a trial marriage period. This perspective suggests that the engagement should last until one of the following occurs:
* The couple gets married (nikah) and starts their conjugal life.
* The couple decides to cancel the engagement (khuliq) due to unforeseen circumstances or changes in their situation.
2. **Reasonable duration**: Other scholars suggest that an engagement should not exceed a reasonable period, typically ranging from a few weeks to several months. This allows both parties to get to know each other better, resolve any potential issues, and make a more informed decision about the marriage.
3. **Customary practices**: In some Muslim-majority countries, engagements can last for extended periods, sometimes even years. For example, in South Asia (e.g., Pakistan and India), it's common for engagements to last several months or up to a year, allowing families to finalize wedding arrangements and make travel plans.

In general, the duration of an engagement should be guided by mutual respect, open communication, and a commitment to fair play. Both parties should strive to maintain a healthy relationship while respecting each other's boundaries and limitations.

Some practical considerations for an Islamic engagement:

1. **Set clear expectations**: Establish a mutually agreeable timeline for the engagement, considering factors like family obligations, financial planning, and personal goals.
2. **Respect each other's boundaries**: Maintain open communication to avoid misunderstandings or hurt feelings. Be willing to adapt and compromise when needed.
3. **Prioritize your intentions**: Remind yourself that an engagement is a temporary arrangement, and the ultimate goal should be a happy and fulfilling marriage.

Ultimately, the length of an engagement in Islam depends on individual circumstances and the couples' shared values. By prioritizing mutual respect, trust, and communication, engaged couples can navigate this period with confidence and prepare for a successful marital journey.


Is 5 years too long to be engaged


The age-old question of engagement length!

In today's society, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. What matters most is whether the couple is happy and committed to each other, regardless of how long they've been engaged.

That being said, here are some points to consider:

**Pros of a longer engagement:**

1. **Financial readiness**: A longer engagement can give you time to pay off debts, build your emergency fund, and save for your future together.
2. **Personal growth**: An engagement lasting 5 years or more can allow each partner to develop their own interests, skills, and independence, making them a stronger couple in the long run.
3. **Travel and exploration**: A longer engagement can provide opportunities to travel, explore new places, and build shared experiences before starting a family.

**Cons of a longer engagement:**

1. **Uncertainty and frustration**: Waiting 5 years or more for the wedding can lead to feelings of uncertainty, frustration, and anxiety about when (or if) the big day will finally arrive.
2. **Drifting apart**: The distance between "I'lls" and "won'ts" can grow, causing the couple to drift apart and potentially lose their initial spark.
3. **Social pressure**: Friends and family may start to wonder if there's a problem with the relationship or if you're just not ready for marriage.

**When is 5 years too long?**

Consider these questions:

1. Are you genuinely happy and fulfilled in your relationship?
2. Are you making progress towards your goals, whether personal or financial?
3. Do you feel like your partner is still committed to the relationship?

If you're answering "no" to any of these questions, it might be worth having an open and honest conversation with your partner about your concerns.

**Ultimately:**

The decision to get married (or not) is a personal choice that depends on individual circumstances. If you're happy, healthy, and committed to each other, 5 years or more of engagement can be a great opportunity for growth and preparation.

However, if you're feeling restless, uncertain, or frustrated about the lack of progress towards your goals, it might be worth reevaluating your priorities and having an open conversation with your partner.