米列娃·馬利奇:不只是「愛因斯坦的妻子」| Nature Podcast

2021-02-13 Nature自然科研

又到了每周一次的 Nature Podcast 時間了!歡迎收聽本周由Benjamin Thompson和 Nick Howe 帶來的一周科學故事,本期播客片段討論米列娃·馬利奇的傳記。歡迎前往iTunes或你喜歡的其他播客平臺下載完整版,隨時隨地收聽一周科研新鮮事。


音頻文本:


Interviewer: Nick Howe

We all know the name Albert Einstein, but what if I said the name Mileva Marić? Well, Marić was a woman highly educated in physics and mathematics. She was also Albert Einstein’s first wife. As they both had similar education, there have been rumours for years that she made contributions to his work, including his famous theory of special relativity. This week in Nature, there is a review of a new biography of Marić. She was born in 1875 in what is now Serbia. Little is known about her early life, but what is known is she was determined to get a higher education. Sadly, in the late 19th century this was a rarity for many women, as Ruth Lewin Sime, a historian of women in science who contributed to the new biography, explains.

Interviewee: Ruth Lewin Sime

It was extraordinarily difficult. I mean the book details Mileva’s girlhood where she was a very bright student but education for girls ended usually at the age of 13 or 14.

Interviewer: Nick Howe

Mileva’s resolve was recognised by her father, Miloš Marić, and he assisted her getting the education required to attend university, an education that was typically not accessible for women.

Interviewee: Ruth Lewin Sime

He helped push for her to be admitted to boys』 schools where she basically got the same education as they did, and that permitted her to go to Switzerland where the universities were open for women, and she entered the university in Zurich at the Polytechnic Institute.

Interviewer: Nick Howe

It was here at the prestigious Zurich Polytechnic, that Marić met a young Albert Einstein. The two had classes together in physics and mathematics and eventually fell in love. At first the pair did similarly academically, but Marić’s grades fell and she was not awarded a diploma. When she went to retake her exams the following year, she was two months pregnant the couple’s first child. This made things difficult.

Interviewee: Ruth Lewin Sime

A pregnancy out of wedlock for a couple that was still trying to get a job and had no security, that was just impossible for them at the time.

Interviewer: Nick Howe

In the end, Marić failed to get her diploma for a second time, deterring her PhD ambitions, and ultimately, she dropped out. The pair lived together and during this period, Einstein had some of his most famous ideas, including special relativity. As such, there are claims that Marić contributed to Einstein’s research by adding ideas and assisting with the mathematics, or that she co-authored some of the early papers, but was never credited. Many of the claims centre on love letters sent between the two. For example, there is one where Einstein refers to 「our work on relative motion」, but historians debate the significance of this, as Marić never refers to the work in her responses. Allen Esterson is the co-author of the new biography and he is not convinced by these claims.

Interviewee: Allen Esterson

We do know that when he was working at the patent office, that was when he produced the great papers of 1905. He did have colleagues at the patent office that he exchanged ideas with, particularly Michele Besso who he acknowledged at the end of the relativity paper as someone who had made valuable suggestions. But as far as is known, we can’t say for sure Mileva made any contribution in that sense. I’m not saying she didn’t, but we simply have no evidence that she did.

Interviewer: Nick Howe

Other historians have said the opposite, arguing that with the two living together, it’s reasonable to think they would have exchanged ideas. The truth is, we’re unlikely to find out the real story. Many of Marić’s letters to Einstein are missing and anyone who may have known more has long since passed away. What is known is that although Marić was a staunch supporter of Einstein, she became unhappy.

Interviewee: Allen Esterson

They were both in love with each other, but once they were married, Einstein soon got totally wrapped up in his work and neglected her. She remained staunchly supportive of him and supplied all his needs, bought up his children, while he was utterly immersed in his work to the extent that he neglected her and that hurt her very badly as we know from letters she wrote to her closest friend.

Interviewer: Nick Howe

Marić wrote about enduring many 「bitter and hard days」 and with the release of Einstein’s famous work she wrote, 「I only hope and wish that fame does not have a harmful effect on his humanity」. Marić also appears melancholy about her lost career in science, and reconciling herself to a domestic role. Their marriage declined to such an extent that Einstein sent Marić a draconian list of demands to allow her to continue to stay with him and the children. These demands included requirements for his laundry to be done and his desk cleaned and that she would, without protest, stop talking to him whenever he demanded it. The pair separated in 1914 and ultimately divorced in 1919. Marić never remarried. She died in 1948, after many years caring for their son Eduard who had schizophrenia and had been institutionalised. Whether or not Marić contributed to Einstein’s work, there is a lot we can learn from her story. Here’s Ruth again.

Interviewee: Ruth Lewin Sime

So, she was in many ways in the forefront of the generation of women that pushed for university education for themselves and of course for other women and it succeeded. By the time that Mileva had finished at her university in Zurich, was just about the time that universities in Germany and Austria were finally opening their doors to women, and it was the accomplishment of women like Mileva that they were able to make this happen.

Interviewer: Nick Howe

That was Ruth Lewin Sime. You also heard from Allen Esterson. You can find a review of their biography of Mileva Marić at nature.com/news. 

 

Nature Podcast每周為您帶來科學世界的全球新聞故事,覆蓋眾多科研領域,重點講述Nature期刊上激動人心的研究故事。我們將話筒遞給研究背後的科學家,呈現來自Nature記者和編輯的深度分析。在2017年,來自中國的收聽和下載超過50萬次,居全球第二。

↓↓iPhone用戶長按二維碼進入iTunes訂閱

 ↓↓安卓用戶長按二維碼進入推薦平臺acast訂閱

點擊「閱讀原文」訪問Nature官網收聽完整版播客

相關焦點

  • 除了是「愛因斯坦的妻子」,她是否對相對論做出了貢獻?
    雖然說馬利奇的功勞可能未得到認可,但這並不意味著她確實有過貢獻,Esterson就此提出了他的反駁論點。Esterson不遺餘力地對每一個資料來源追根究底,分析推敲。比如,他發現愛因斯坦在使用「我們」和「我們的」這些詞時,並非指向某次實際合作,並給出了如下理由:馬利奇本人似乎從未提到過狹義相對論,也沒有在自己寫的信裡重複上述代詞,而且她可能不具備探討該話題的條件。雖然Esterson的陳述非常詳盡,但有些雜亂無章,部分原因在於他對某些資料來源的每一次重複引用都做了分析。
  • 愛因斯坦妻子的「秘密貢獻」,你了解嗎?
    愛因斯坦和他的第一任妻子米列娃文/盧昌海1989年2月,美國的《今日物理學》雜誌刊登了沃克癌症研究所創始人沃克的一篇標題為《愛因斯坦用了他妻子的想法嗎?》的文章。首先是假博士(因為博士論文是妻子「代筆」的),其次是沽名釣譽之輩(因為狹義相對論的想法和數學表述都是妻子「贊助」的),甚至還是陰險之徒(因為銷毀信件,並用金錢封口)。附帶著被顛覆的還有整個科學史學界(因為有意抹殺米列娃的貢獻)。如此顛覆歷史——乃至顛覆史學界——的觀點證據何在?
  • 愛因斯坦:妻子和妓女的區別僅在於……
    「我對自己的雙親非常了解。他們認為妻子是男人的奢侈品,只有在他過著富裕的生活時才能擁有。我對這種男人與妻子間的關係的看法評價很低,因為它使妻子和妓女的區別僅在於前者——由於她那較高的社會層次——從男人那裡得到了一紙終身合同。」
  • 世界上最讓我難以理解的就是所得稅|愛因斯坦誕辰140周年
    17歲時,愛因斯坦進入蘇黎世聯邦理工學院學習物理。他在那裡遇到了第一任妻子米列娃·馬利奇。同班六名學生中,米列娃是唯一女性,她比愛因斯坦大三歲。愛因斯坦與第一任妻子米列娃然而,大學畢業後有兩年時間,愛因斯坦都處於失業狀態。後來在父親的幫助下,才找到一份專利局的工作。他利用業餘時間摸魚搞科研,時常和朋友一起討論科學和哲學。
  • 愛因斯坦為他的妻子寫下一份不寒而慄的要求清單!
    愛因斯坦幾乎立即就出軌了,他開始與他的表妹艾爾莎發生婚外情,他與馬裡奇離婚後娶了艾爾莎。他對艾爾莎也不忠誠,因為他在娶艾爾莎的同時還維持著好幾段婚外情,甚至利用他的繼女給他的一些情婦寫信。對於他的兩個妻子,愛因斯坦對他的出軌行為幾乎沒有任何悔意。事實上,他對自己的婚外情是相當坦率的。
  • 愛因斯坦桌子不讓妻子碰,梵谷玻璃心才割耳....天才們的房(si sheng)間(huo)什麼樣?
    而小編就十分好奇天才的房(si sheng)間(huo)和我們有什麼不一樣!天才一號:愛因斯坦潔癖到漫天都是書的房間在大家眼中,愛因斯坦是一個充滿靈感而溫和的人。但其實愛因斯坦有過兩次婚姻,並且與妻子關係都不太好。
  • 愛因斯坦離婚時付不起贍養費,卻說了16個字,妻子毫不猶豫答應
    愛因斯坦是一位享譽世界的科學家,在科學上的壯舉,影響至今。但今天不介紹他的成就,而是給大家說一下他婚姻生活。愛因斯坦娶過兩個妻子,在40歲的時候主動提出和第一任妻子離婚,按照法律規定,他應該要支付妻子贍養費,但此時的愛因斯坦收入並不高,因此掏不出錢。
  • 阿爾伯特·愛因斯坦(上)
    愛因斯坦的父親很希望愛因斯坦能夠繼承他的電機工程事業,但愛因斯坦對這不感興趣,他認為對他而言這是大材小用。1896年,年僅17歲的愛因斯坦獲準進入蘇黎世聯邦理工學院師範係數理科學習物理。他在那裡遇到未來妻子米列娃·馬利奇。同班六名學生中,米列娃是唯一女性,她比愛因斯坦大三歲。愛因斯坦與米列娃在物理方面有共同的興趣與目標,久而久之漸漸擦出愛情火花。
  • 《賈伯斯傳》作者:曾披露愛因斯坦給妻子的家規
    在《賈伯斯傳》之前,他已經為基辛格、富蘭克林和愛因斯坦寫過傳記。在艾薩克森的筆下,人物往往會展現出其他傳記作家所無法挖掘的層次感;他清楚地認識到,讀者想看的是故事,而不是教材。他說自己要寫的是「甜甜圈式」的傳記,即一定要有美味的主題。
  • 【北京保利2016信札秋拍】1914年愛因斯坦致分居妻子米列娃家書展現天才另一面
    1903年,愛因斯坦與塞爾維亞姑娘米列娃·馬裡奇結婚。米列娃是愛因斯坦的大學同學,她是物理班的高材生,同時也與愛因斯坦一樣有著獨立的思想和固執的個性。婚後,米列娃對愛因斯坦的生活和工作都給予了極大支持,包括她對愛因斯坦的《狹義相對論》等多個重要論文中大量數據的計算和核實。1904年,他們的兒子出世,取名漢斯·阿爾伯特。
  • 愛因斯坦的第一位女友、兩任妻子、多個情人及他的孩子們!
    可是進了大學不久,愛因斯坦就單方面結束了與瑪麗的戀人關係,並且寫了一封信向瑪麗的母親致歉。在經過幾年的消沉後,瑪麗後來嫁給了一個手錶廠的經理。愛因斯坦一生結過兩次婚。第一任妻子是他蘇黎世聯邦理工學院的同學,塞爾維亞女數學家米列娃·瑪麗克。
  • 愛因斯坦發明了原子彈?不,他只是和平的捍衛者
    質能方程只是闡述了質量和能量的關係,表明的質量和能量是統一的,能夠用來解釋為什麼核反應會釋放出這麼多的能量,但是不能解釋為什麼會發生核反應。愛因斯坦在1905年提出質能方程的時候,湯姆遜已經發現了原子中存在電子,雖然原子內部結構模型滿天飛,但是物理學家盧瑟福在1912年才發現了原子核的存在,愛因斯坦當時根本不可能知道自然界中存在核反應。
  • 愛因斯坦與妻子都是學術天才,為何生的三個孩子中兩個是精神病?
    緣分的相遇與學校的戀情著名的科學家愛因斯坦,他的智商可以說的上是極高了,而他的妻子自然也不是普通之人,亦是科學界中的天才。然而就是如此天才的二人,他們所生的孩子,三個之中有兩個是「精神病」其中又是什麼原因呢?
  • Nature Podcast: 是什麼讓「獨孤蝗」變身「災難蝗」?
    We couldn’t get hold of the authors for this podcast, but reporter Geoff Marsh spoke to entomologist Leslie Vosshall from the Rockerfeller University in New York.
  • 不讓愛因斯坦談相對論的頒獎大會?諾貝爾獎與愛因斯坦荒誕的故事
    百年以來,獲獎的過千人百人中,各類大牛,故事層不出差。但是這些舉世矚目的任務中,愛因斯坦是獲得諾貝獎的名人中,和諾貝爾獎故事最多的人。同時,愛因斯坦還與中國發生了一些故事,他是為數不多曾幫助過中國的外國科學家,能算是中國人的朋友了。一、未獲諾貝爾物理學獎前,就在離婚協議中與妻子分割諾貝爾獎金的人。
  • 你以為愛因斯坦只是個沉迷科學的老頭?他風流成性 擁有10位情婦
    你以為愛因斯坦只是個沉迷科學的老頭? 他風流成性 有10位情婦提起愛因斯坦你會想到什麼?人類歷史最偉大的物理學家?沉迷物理學研究的宅男?一個邋遢頭髮發白穿著拖鞋的老人?恐怕沒人會把一個風流成性,情人無數的形象安在這位偉大的科學家身上吧。
  • 只是不知道――愛因斯坦不喜中國之我見
    愛因斯坦在大國受到的尊重,也許全球沒有地方可比,畢竟曾經幾十年,他的畫像幾乎貼滿了從小學到大學外加文化場所。但他確實不喜歡大國,有很多針對大國帶著歧視、偏見甚至侮辱的語言――線上已展示得琳琅滿目,這裡就不引用了。愛因斯坦為什麼會如此對待大國?其實是他真不知道大國,當然也是西方政客與媒體誤導的結果。
  • 兩任妻子、十多個情人,愛因斯坦的私生活比教科書裡精彩多了
    比如愛因斯坦,我們在教科書上看到的他,往往是如下圖這樣充滿智慧的偉人形象。而事實上,這個世人眼中的天才,卻有著不為人知的另一面。生活中的他,是個會在照相時向鏡頭吐舌頭賣萌的怪老頭。除了物理學上的偉大成就,他的個人情史,更令人嘆為觀止——有兩任妻子、十餘個情人。
  • 愛因斯坦:時間根本不存在,人類只是被記憶蒙蔽了,是真的嗎?
    愛因斯坦:時間根本不存在,人類只是被記憶蒙蔽了,是真的嗎?愛因斯坦曾經說過一句話:時間其實根本不存在,人類只是被記憶蒙蔽了而已。不管愛因斯坦的這句話說的是真是假,時間都是個真實的存在。時間我們一直都認為它只是一個抽象的概念。