Black Hole Orbits(1) (English)

2021-02-13 PhysicsWhiz

After a thorogh discussion about black holes and the Schwarzschild metric, we will now look at how objects move around a black hole, or any spherical, uniform mass. 

How might we obtain an equation of motion?

In a system without any external force, objects follow the "least" path. On a flat surface, this is simply just a straight segment connecting two points. In the 4-dimensional spacetime, this least path (or the geodesics) describes the motion of the object. In Minkowski space, the geodesics is a line, with a time dimension.

What about curved space?

Consider a spherical surface--a curved 2-dimensional space. The shortest path now isn't a straight line. It is in fact a great circle connecting the points, that is, a circle with its center at the center of the sphere, and its radius equal to that of the sphere. In a more complicated curved space, the geodesics is what makes the spacetime interval (as described by the metric) take its extreme value. Sounds like Fermat's principle, eh?

A great circle

For any metric given to us, we can calculate the geodesics using a method known as calculus of variations. In fact, we could write the interval as:

L is any function, and λ is a parameter factored out of L. (It is named the affine parameter). Note that the dot on x, y, z signifies derivative with respect to λ. To give the extremal interval, it can be shown that x,y,z satisfies the Euler-Lagrange equations, or:

(The Euler-Lagrange equations are commonly used in classical mechanics with the notion of "Lagrangian")

Now with all these tools, we can finally look at the metric!

We take the affine parameter in this case to be the proper time, or the time as measured in the object's own frame. Recall the definition of proper time in the schwarzschild metric:

that is, the spacetime interval when dr = 0. This means we could write:

and hence (with L = 1):

taking the negative square root of ds, we obtain the following information of L:

L is now dependent on the 4 variables: t, r, φ and θ. All that is left is for us to plug in the equations, and Voila! so easy~~

The 4 variables give us the for equations. For t:

The lack of dependence on t in L shows that there is in fact a conserved quantity:

Where E/m is the energy per mass.  Expanding, we have:

Why do we call it E/m? The argument is that, for large r, this reduces down to the Minkowski metric, and for the Minkowski metric,

for φ,θ, the same calculations holds. We define the following:

to be the angular momentum per mass. this is simpler to understand than E/m. (Simply recall the definition of θ in a spherical system)

The existence of the sinθ term means there isn't a conserved quantity for θ. We write:

r's equations of motion are quite difficult to obtain using the Euler-Lagrange equations. Instead, we use the definition of L that L = L^2 = 1:

When looking orbits in a single plane, θ=π/2, so that it reduces to:

Now we plug in the conserved quantities, the energy per mass and angular momentum per mass:

Basic algbera to separate the variables give:

Finally, the art of guessing allows us to plug back all the c's (also known as dimensional analysis), so that finally we obtain the equation:

And this is our equation of motion.

No aspects of the black hole are actually discussed during our work--these equations fit any spherically uniform mass. To solve explicitly for r is very difficult indeed, so we use approximations...

Nope. Sadly, no approximation exists. We will instead use the method of effective potential to discuss all of the possible orbits. Finally, an interesting case to note is the light orbit. Newtonian physics gives no light orbits. Light goes in a straight line. But in general relativity, light in fact is curved (and red-shifted) near masses. Such facts has already been confirmed with gravitational lensing, but what's more interesting is the existence of a light circular orbit.

...And all of that is for next time!

相關焦點

  • Black hole picture unveiled for the first time
    Photo provided by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) shows the first image of a black hole.(Xinhua/EHT)The image shows a crescent-shaped, ring-like structure with a dark central region -- the black hole's shadow.
  • 每日一歌 | supermassive black hole
    《black holes and revelations》2006-6-28Supermassive Black
  • Black Hole Orbits(1)
    而由於本徵時間和時空間隔相等,L=1,即由於我們所考慮的環繞軌道處於同一平面上,我們可以先暫時研究θ=π/2時的運動。方程簡化為:
  • 被Black hole刷屏,我只想簡單地學點英語……
    就是:「black」(黑)+「hole」(洞)=black hole(黑洞)雖然從照片看,它不是那麼黑,也不太像個洞。桌子像black hole?還有這種操作?如果說一個地方像black hole,意思是東西總在這個地方神秘消失,而且再也找不回來 (irretrievably lost)。
  • 視頻 | Katie Bouman: How to take a picture of a black hole
    這位被譽為「首張黑洞照片背後的女人」(The woman behind the first black hole image),是為年僅29歲的科學家。本文一起來聽聽她在2017年的TED演講How to take a picture of a black hole,如何拍攝黑洞照片?
  • TED視頻分享 | How to take a picture of a black hole —— Katie Bouman
    We may be seeing our first picture of a black hole in the next couple years.  8:21 But when it comes to images from the black hole, we're posed with a real conundrum: we've never seen a black hole before.
  • 【Seminar】Black hole information paradox from my point of view
    In this two talks, I will talk about black hole information paradox from gravitational physics. Next, I will formulate the paradox associated with the evaporating and eternal black hole.
  • 眾多美劇裡的熱門插曲,聽不膩 | Supermassive Black Hole
    讓我的靈魂space shields melting in the dead of night宛如冰河在深夜融化and the superstars sucked into the supermassive超級星體也被無際黑洞吞噬set my soul讓我的靈魂Supermassive black
  • TutorABC英語課堂:揭開黑洞神秘的面紗,黑洞black hole知多少
    黑洞英文就是black hole, 對我們而言,黑洞一直是非常神秘的事物。在廣義相對論中,黑洞是宇宙空間內存在的一種天體,它的引力非常之大,甚至連光都無法逃逸出它的「魔爪」。一直以來,黑洞的形象始存在於大家的想像和計算機模擬之中。直到幾天前,科學家們終於拍攝到了首張黑洞照片。
  • 【雙語彙】Black hole and EHT 黑洞與事件視界望遠鏡
    最近,人類拍攝到的首張黑洞(black hole)照片公布,終於揭開了宇宙中這一「看不見、摸不著」天體的神秘面紗。
  • 「雙語彙」Black hole and EHT 黑洞與事件視界望遠鏡
    最近,人類拍攝到的首張黑洞(black hole)照片公布,終於揭開了宇宙中這一「看不見、摸不著」天體的神秘面紗。多少年來,由於觀測手段和計算能力有限,黑洞一直停留在理論物理學家的預測中。人們只能偶爾在科幻電影中遐想黑洞的「面容」。
  • Black holes:Staring into the abyss 凝視宇宙深淵
    核心表達掃描:1.And they are defined by having gravitational fields so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape them.
  • 劉志斌、李傑領跑2018「N·S blackhole杯」LTW揭幕戰!
    劉志斌、李傑領跑2018「N·S杯」LTW揭幕戰北京時間3月17日,由《路亞時代》全程策劃、LTW賽事組委會主辦、廣東韶關狂人國際路亞基地承辦的2018「N·S blackhole杯」LTW 全國巡迴賽揭幕戰在廣東韶關國際路亞基地盛大召開,本次比賽吸引了來自全國28組56人參與,可謂高手對決,值得一提的是
  • 法老之蛇無毒版 Black Snake
    Therefore, an alternative option is the black snake experiment: in ideal conditions, it has exactly the same effect as the Pharaoh’s Serpent, but all reactants and products are non-toxic.